A.P. Herbert
I have been in France. There are some poplars still,
And Norman spires unwounded on the hill:
I saw the slaughtered cities but I saw
The flags of freedom, and the lamps of law.
I saw Montgomery, tremendous man,
Loosing the lightning from a caravan,
Crusading calmly in his corduroys,
The coolest thunderbolt the King employs.
I saw his weary soldiers, in the dust,
Salute with love, and not because they must:
For he has won the battle of belief,
And Cockneys are Crusaders, like ‘the Chief.
I saw the beaches, and, with humble feet,
Walked in the wake of the Crusaders’ Fleet:
I saw the ships, a never-ending chain,
That makes the Channel English once again.
And I remembered-five short years before
Some German said that England was no more.
© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes
Analysis (AI Assisted)
This war poem is both reflective and triumphant, capturing the transformation of France and England during and after World War II. It blends personal observation with a historical perspective, offering a nuanced reflection on victory and the endurance of national identity.
The speaker begins with a description of post-war France. The mention of “poplars still” and “Norman spires unwounded on the hill” invokes a sense of continuity in the midst of destruction, suggesting that even though France has suffered heavily, some of its iconic landmarks remain intact. This fleeting image of resilience is set against the “slaughtered cities,” implying that while the war has caused significant damage, the spirit of the land and its people is not easily destroyed. The reference to the “flags of freedom” and “the lamps of law” is a subtle nod to the survival of ideals that define democratic nations, despite the war’s brutal toll. The flags are symbols of the larger moral struggle, and the lamps may refer to hope, knowledge, or the guiding principles that still shine through the darkness of conflict.
Then, the poem shifts focus to the British general Bernard Montgomery, who is depicted as a “tremendous man” and a “coolest thunderbolt” – a powerful, calm force of nature amidst chaos. Montgomery’s coolness, symbolized by “corduroys” and his unpretentious attire, contrasts sharply with the violent nature of war. He is presented as a figure who exudes both authority and humanity, a man who wins the “battle of belief” – meaning his leadership was not only tactical but also inspirational. Montgomery’s soldiers “salute with love” because they believe in him, suggesting the depth of respect and admiration he earned from those under his command. The phrase “Cockneys are Crusaders, like ‘the Chief'” emphasizes the unification of different classes and regions within Britain, all rallying together under Montgomery’s leadership in a common cause.
The next section of the poem takes the speaker to the beaches, where he “walked in the wake of the Crusaders’ Fleet,” which recalls the iconic D-Day landing at Normandy. The “Crusaders’ Fleet” evokes the image of an army embarked on a righteous mission, a holy cause that harkens back to the medieval Crusades. This comparison elevates the historical significance of the operation and underscores the idea that the British and their allies were not just fighting for territorial gains, but for moral and ideological victories.
The final lines of the poem bring the reader back to England, emphasizing the enduring nature of the nation’s spirit. “The Channel English once again” suggests that, despite the hardships of war, Britain has reclaimed its place and its pride. The mention of “five short years before” recalls the dark days of 1940 when it was uncertain whether England could survive the war at all. The line “Some German said that England was no more” is a reminder of the dire predictions made by the Axis powers, particularly after the fall of France, when it seemed as if Britain might be next in line for invasion or defeat. The closing lines are a subtle but powerful affirmation of national resilience, a quiet statement that the enemy’s predictions were wrong and that England, though battered, remains undiminished.
The poem combines historical insight with a deeply personal perspective, conveying not only the physical progress of the war but also the emotional and psychological toll it took on the people involved. By focusing on Montgomery and the “Crusaders,” it casts the British forces as fighting not just for survival, but for a higher purpose, one that resonates with themes of justice, freedom, and honor. Through these observations, the poem highlights both the destruction wrought by war and the strength, unity, and hope that helped lead to eventual victory. The speaker’s final reflection – that England “was no more” according to the Germans – stands as a testament to the unshakeable resolve of the British people, who defied the odds and ensured that the country would endure.