Ewart Alan Mackintosh
When you and I are buried
With grasses over head,
The memory of our fights will stand
Above this bare and tortured land,
We knew ere we were dead.
Though grasses grow on Vimy,
And poppies at Messines,
And in High Wood the children play,
The craters and the graves will stay
To show what things have been.
Though all be quiet in day-time,
The night shall bring a change,
And peasants walking home shall see
Shell-torn meadow and riven tree,
And their own fields grown strange.
They shall hear live men crying,
They shall see dead men lie,
Shall hear the rattling Maxims fire,
And see by broken twists of wire
Gold flares light up the sky.
And in their new-built houses
The frightened folk will see
Pale bombers coming down the street,
And hear the flurry of charging feet,
And the crash of Victory.
This is our Earth baptized
With the red wine of War.
Horror and courage hand in hand
Shall brood upon the stricken land
In silence evermore.
© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes
Analysis (AI Assisted)
This poem meditates on the lasting impact of war, specifically the First World War, on both the land and the people who lived through it. With stark, haunting imagery, it explores the way in which the scars of battle endure long after the fighting has ceased, leaving a permanent mark on the landscape and the collective memory of those who are left behind. The speaker imagines a time when they and others like them are buried in the earth, their bodies overtaken by nature, but the memory of their struggles and sacrifices will remain—etched into the land itself.
From the outset, the poem juxtaposes the natural imagery of “grasses over head” with the violent reality of war. The graves and the memory of the soldiers’ “fights” are set to endure, symbolized by the “bare and tortured land” that was once the site of such immense suffering. This line highlights the contrast between the peaceful imagery of nature and the horrific history that lies beneath it. The poem suggests that while nature may grow over the scars of war, it will never truly erase them.
The references to specific battle sites—Vimy, Messines, and High Wood—anchor the poem in the geography of the war, evoking the sense that these locations are forever marked by their violent history. The imagery of “grasses grow on Vimy” and “poppies at Messines” calls to mind the famous symbol of remembrance, but also emphasizes that the land may heal in one way, while the emotional and historical scars remain in another. The craters, graves, and the remnants of battle—such as “craters and graves” and “broken twists of wire”—are stark symbols of the past that refuse to fade away. The land, though it may appear calm on the surface, carries within it the memory of destruction, death, and the chaos of war.
The middle stanzas turn to the idea of time and how it shifts the perspective of those who inherit the land after the war. The peaceful image of “peasants walking home” is interrupted by the return of the violence they never truly left behind. The “shell-torn meadow and riven tree” and the sounds of “rattling Maxims fire” evoke a scene of war that seems to transcend time, as if the land itself continues to hold the echoes of the past. The night, which should offer a sense of calm, instead brings the “change” of war’s haunting presence. The “gold flares” that light up the sky suggest the surreal and nightmarish quality of the battlefield, where the sky itself seems to reflect the violence below. The line “And in their new-built houses” brings a striking contrast between the optimism of rebuilding and the inescapable presence of war that will forever haunt these spaces.
In the closing stanzas, the poem shifts again to a broader reflection on the permanence of war’s legacy. The soldiers’ Earth, “baptized with the red wine of War,” is a powerful metaphor for the bloodshed that has soaked the land. The “red wine” could symbolize both the sacrifice of soldiers and the relentless nature of violence that continues to define the land. The pairing of “horror and courage hand in hand” reinforces the paradoxical and coexisting forces of war: the overwhelming fear and the indomitable bravery required to face it. These two forces, the poem suggests, will forever haunt the land, lingering in silence even after the war itself has ended.
Ultimately, the poem conveys a sense of futility in the attempt to erase the horrors of war from memory. The land may eventually be covered over with new life, and the people who live in the aftermath may rebuild their homes, but the violence, fear, and loss will persist in the air, the earth, and the very memory of those who were affected. The poem reminds us that while time may bring healing, it cannot undo the deep scars left by war—scars that, in a way, become part of the identity of both the land and its people.
This is a poem about the haunting permanence of war, the way it shapes both the physical landscape and the cultural memory of those who live in its wake. There is no real resolution, no peace that comes after the fighting ends, only an eerie continuity of violence and loss that forever marks the land and its people. The ghosts of the past—both soldiers and civilians—linger, and the poem leaves us with the stark recognition that war’s true cost is not just measured in the lives lost but in the eternal presence of its scars, which can never fully fade.