Leon Gellert
Again the clash is East, the Gates are barred.
The rolling echoes of of Troy arise
With trebled sound: its weary threshold scarred
With scattered dead once more, and wild with cries.
The noise that dinned when siting Hellas reeled
Before the brave defence of Hector’s horde,
The blows that burst on Agamemmnon’s shield,
Or echoed from Achilles’ threshing sword
Were weak and small. Before this mighty blast
They seem the tinklings of a timid past.
To-day the Grecian arms are still and deep
Within the tomb: those heroes deep in dust;
The eyes of Attic honour closed with sleep,
And wise Ulysses’ arrows red with rust.
© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes
Analysis (AI Assisted)
This poem presents a vivid and striking meditation on the nature of war, time, and the shifting significance of past heroism. Drawing on classical imagery, particularly from *The Iliad* and the mythic history of ancient Greece, the speaker evokes the great clash at Troy and contrasts it with the “mighty blast” of contemporary warfare. The weight of history is felt throughout the poem, as the speaker moves from recounting the grandeur of past battles to confronting the present horrors of war.
The opening lines set the stage by invoking the “clash” of battle, immediately drawing a parallel to the fall of Troy. The phrase “the Gates are barred” suggests an inescapable conflict, a battle that is destined to unfold once again in the shadow of ancient violence. The “rolling echoes of Troy” serve as both a literal and metaphorical reminder that history repeats itself. The “weary threshold scarred” with “scattered dead” highlights the ongoing cycle of destruction and death. Even as the speaker reflects on the past, the presence of death and destruction seems to bleed into the present, as if the wounds of Troy have never truly healed.
The reference to “the blows that burst on Agamemnon’s shield” and the “echoed” sounds of Achilles’ sword emphasizes the grandeur and heroism of ancient battles. Yet, the poem quickly shifts, suggesting that these once mighty struggles were “weak and small” when compared to the contemporary “mighty blast” of war. The “tinklings of a timid past” is a striking expression, suggesting that the heroic tales of old, once viewed as epic and profound, now seem like faint echoes, almost inconsequential in the face of modern warfare’s overwhelming violence. The clash of Achilles’ spear, the thundering force of Hector’s defense, and the final fall of Troy are all dwarfed by the magnitude of current conflict.
In the latter part of the poem, the speaker meditates on the passage of time and the fate of those legendary figures. “To-day the Grecian arms are still and deep / Within the tomb,” the speaker notes, acknowledging the physical death of the warriors who once embodied honor, strength, and bravery. The idea of “wise Ulysses’ arrows red with rust” poignantly illustrates the decay of mythic heroism. Ulysses, once the embodiment of cunning and heroism, is reduced to a relic — his arrows rusting, his wisdom fading into the past.
There is a deep sense of futility in these lines, a reflection on how the once-great figures of history have been swallowed by time and death. The emphasis on “dust” and “sleep” suggests a kind of finality — a loss of the grandeur and ideals that these figures once symbolized. The mention of Ulysses’ arrows in particular invokes the idea of heroism as a tool, something that has become useless and obsolete in the face of the new and more brutal reality of modern conflict.
In terms of structure, the poem adopts a classical feel, with its measured lines and balanced rhythm. This form serves to reflect the historical nature of the references, lending a timeless quality to the poem. At the same time, the weight of history is felt throughout the work, as the speaker confronts the grim reality of the present moment. While the classical references provide a sense of grandeur, they are framed in the context of loss, decay, and the realization that even the most heroic of tales cannot escape the passage of time.
Ultimately, the poem seems to reflect a lament for the erosion of ideals and the futility of human struggle. The ancient battles of Troy, once the pinnacle of human heroism, now seem pale and insignificant compared to the ongoing horrors of war. The speaker seems to question the value of heroism in the face of modern violence, suggesting that the “mighty blast” of the present renders past glories obsolete. By invoking the dust and rust of history, the poem mourns not only the loss of the heroes of Troy but also the loss of any sense of lasting purpose or meaning in the endless cycle of war. The shifting significance of these ancient struggles is a sobering commentary on the ongoing violence that defines the human experience.