The Advice Of Treachery

Leon Gellert

This well-feigned trance, this still and
        stupored sleep
is aptly timed, and nobly fits the scheme.
The cloud-encircled Sword with Night may creep
Beside the gates, and catch the world adream,
Snatching as life before the sluggish breath
Awakes to morning and to vultured death,
Till Craft appeared, the blunted Grecian spears
  That scratched at Troy, and all the blistered
              Hands
That tore at stones and prayed upon the sands
Were weak and vain, and vain the bloody years.
Oh, let the winds take up the heavy tones
Of  sleeping.  Move within a mist! Shun light!
Then swing the hidden weapon once, and smite,
And gaze with laughter on the slaughtered throne.

© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes

Analysis (AI Assisted)

This war poem is heavy with a sense of tragic irony and a deep contemplation of violence, fate, and the futility of human effort. The speaker begins with an image of feigned or artificial sleep, a “well-feigned trance,” which sets the tone for the poem’s exploration of illusion and the fragile line between life and death. This “still and stupored sleep” seems like a metaphor for the way humans go through the motions of life, unaware of or indifferent to the violence and suffering that are inevitable.

The imagery of the “cloud-encircled Sword” is striking and ominous, invoking a sense of impending doom or violence that looms in the background, waiting to strike. The “Sword with Night” feels like an allusion to death or destruction, suggesting that war is an ever-present force, creeping in the shadows, “beside the gates” as the world sleeps. The idea of “life before the sluggish breath / Awakens to morning and to vultured death” introduces an interesting juxtaposition — the “sluggish breath” being the slow, reluctant return to consciousness, while “vultured death” evokes the sense of inevitable, predatory violence that follows war.

The poem moves from the general to the specific, referencing the fall of Troy and the famed Grecian warriors, whose once-strong spears “scratched at Troy.” Here, the image of “blunted Grecian spears” speaks to the impotence and failure of war. The “blistered hands” are an uncomfortable image — the hands that once tore at the stones of Troy now seem to be weak and ineffective. The focus on these hands, marked by wear and toil, emphasizes the brutality and futility of the long, drawn-out conflict. This futile struggle reflects the larger theme of the poem: that human effort in the face of violence and war is often meaningless.

The speaker then shifts to a vision of “Craft” appearing — a reference to the trickery or deception that played a pivotal role in the fall of Troy (most notably through the Trojan Horse). This suggestion of deception underscores the falsehoods that often accompany war, and perhaps, the illusion of progress or victory in battle. The entire ordeal of war, with its “blunted spears” and “blistered hands,” is rendered meaningless. The “bloody years” are described as “vain,” underscoring the speaker’s sense of hopelessness about the futility of warfare.

The closing lines offer a stark contrast to the earlier lament. The winds take up “heavy tones of sleeping,” implying that war and death are inevitable and unstoppable forces, like sleep itself. The idea of moving “within a mist” and shunning light suggests an embrace of the unknown or the dark forces at work in conflict. The final command, “Then swing the hidden weapon once, and smite, / And gaze with laughter on the slaughtered throne,” is chilling. It implies that violence, once inevitable, becomes almost laughable — a grotesque and dark triumph that comes with no real glory, only destruction.

The entire poem is steeped in a bitter, reflective tone, contemplating not just the futility of war, but the disillusionment that follows. By using images of sleep, blunted weapons, and the dark forces of violence, the poem paints a grim portrait of humanity’s relationship with war. The laughter at the end is deeply unsettling, reinforcing the idea that war is not only futile, but also destructive in ways that mock the very notion of honor or glory. The final smite, the “hidden weapon,” is both an act of aggression and an acceptance of the violence that is inevitable, leaving the reader with a haunting sense of resigned nihilism.

Discover more from War Poetry

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading