Robert Graves
And what of home–how goes it, boys,
While we die here in stench and noise?
“The hill stands up and hedges wind
Over the crest and drop behind;
Here swallows dip and wild things go
On peaceful errands to and fro
Across the sloping meadow floor,
And make no guess at blasting war.
In woods that fledge the round hill-shoulder
Leaves shoot and open, fall and moulder,
And shoot again. Meadows yet show
Alternate white of drifted snow
And daisies. Children play at shop,
Warm days, on the flat boulder-top,
With wildflower coinage, and the wares
Are bits of glass and unripe pears.
Crows perch upon the backs of sheep,
The wheat goes yellow: women reap,
Autumn winds ruffle brook and pond,
Flutter the hedge and fly beyond.
So the first things of nature run,
And stand not still for any one,
Contemptuous of the distant cry
Wherewith you harrow earth and sky.
And high French clouds, praying to be
Back, back in peace beyond the sea,
Where nature with accustomed round
Sweeps and garnishes the ground
With kindly beauty, warm or cold–
Alternate seasons never old:
Heathen, how furiously you rage,
Cursing this blood and brimstone age,
How furiously against your will
You kill and kill again, and kill:
All thought of peace behind you cast,
Till like small boys with fear aghast,
Each cries for God to understand,
‘I could not help it, it was my hand.'”
© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes
Analysis (AI Assisted)
This poem reflects on the stark contrast between the brutal, chaotic reality of war and the peaceful, natural world that continues unperturbed back home. It captures the tension between the soldiers on the battlefield, immersed in violence and suffering, and the idyllic scenes of life on the home front, where nature and human activity unfold in cycles of calm and renewal. Yet the war, with all its destruction and death, persists as an all-consuming force that erodes the natural rhythms of life.
The opening lines immediately establish the despair of soldiers at the front, “while we die here in stench and noise.” The tone is grim and heavy, suggesting a suffocating environment both physically and mentally. This is a battlefield where the air is thick with the stench of decay, and the noise is constant—perhaps the explosions, the shouting, the cries of wounded comrades. The “hill stands up and hedges wind” back home, a poetic way of indicating that, while war rages, the natural world remains untouched, untouched by the horrors men are enduring in its name.
The next few lines vividly describe the rural tranquility of the homefront. The “hill” stands proudly, the “hedges wind,” and life proceeds with its usual rhythm. Swallows “dip” in peaceful flight, and wild creatures go about their business, unaware of the violence consuming the soldiers’ world. There is a sense of permanence and cyclical renewal here, with nature continuing its timeless dance. Leaves shoot, open, fall, and moulder; meadows show “alternate white of drifted snow / And daisies.” The ordinary activities of life—children playing, women reaping, and animals grazing—are presented as serene and unaffected by the war.
The scene contrasts sharply with the soldiers’ plight. Life at home, with its “peaceful errands,” is untouched by the bombs and the bloodshed. The image of children playing with “wildflower coinage” and “bits of glass and unripe pears” evokes innocence and simplicity, further emphasizing the contrast between home and the horrors the soldiers face. These images are also a reminder that, while the soldiers fight and die in the trenches, the world outside continues, seemingly oblivious to their struggle.
But this peace is disrupted as the speaker shifts focus to the soldiers’ internal conflict and confusion. The “high French clouds, praying to be / Back, back in peace beyond the sea” represent a longing for peace, for the return to the natural order where seasons change but life remains constant. But war interrupts this cycle. The soldiers are caught in an age of “blood and brimstone,” a violent era where their actions are driven by forces beyond their control. The “heathen” of the soldiers’ rage is ironic— they kill “against your will,” with no true desire for the bloodshed they cause. They are forced into violence, driven by duty, fear, or self-preservation, yet they still cry out for absolution from God.
The final lines present a powerful image of guilt and helplessness. The soldiers’ cries, “I could not help it, it was my hand,” express their internal struggle with the violence they are compelled to enact. They are caught between their duty and the moral weight of their actions. The repetition of “kill and kill again” underscores the futility and senselessness of war. The soldiers are trapped in a cycle of destruction, each one struggling to justify their actions, and yet unable to escape the compulsion of war.
The poem’s juxtaposition of the serene, cyclical life of nature with the destructive, cyclical violence of war serves as a meditation on the unnaturalness of conflict. The soldiers’ lives are disrupted, and the world they fight for seems distant, even out of reach. The contrast between home and the battlefield is not just geographical but existential. The war forces the soldiers to abandon the rhythm of nature, to leave behind the innocence of home, and to confront the brutality of their own actions. Yet, in the end, they are powerless to stop the destruction. They kill, not from desire but from necessity, and as they do, they long for peace, for a return to the natural order they have been violently torn from.
This poem captures the tragic irony of war: while nature and life continue on, unchanging, the soldiers find themselves irrevocably altered by their involvement in violence. It suggests that the real victims of war are not just the fallen soldiers but the very fabric of human life, torn apart by forces beyond anyone’s control. It is an elegy not just for the dead but for the innocence lost when humans are forced into conflict, and for the world that must endure the scars of war long after the fighting has stopped.