Siegfried Sassoon
(To Robert Graves)
I
Here I’m sitting in the gloom
Of my quiet attic room.
France goes rolling all around,
Fledged with forest May has crowned.
And I puff my pipe, calm-hearted,
Thinking how the fighting started,
Wondering when we’ll ever end it,
Back to hell with Kaiser sent it,
Gag the noise, pack up and go,
Clockwork soldiers in a row.
I’ve got better things to do
Than to waste my time on you.
II
Robert, when I drowse to-night,
Skirting lawns of sleep to chase
Shifting dreams in mazy light,
Somewhere then I’ll see your face
Turning back to bid me follow
Where I wag my arms and hollo,
Over hedges hasting after
Crooked smile and baffling laughter,
Running tireless, floating, leaping,
Down your web-hung woods and valleys,
Where the glowworm stars are peeping,
Till I find you, quiet as stone
On a hill-top all alone,
Staring outward, gravely pondering
Jumbled leagues of hillock-wandering.
III
You and I have walked together
In the starving winter weather.
We’ve been glad because we knew
Time’s too short and friends are few.
We’ve been sad because we missed
One whose yellow head was kissed
By the gods, who thought about him
Till they couldn’t do without him.
Now he’s here again; I’ve been
Soldier David dressed in green,
Standing in a wood that swings
To the madrigal he sings.
He’s come back, all mirth and glory,
Like the prince in a fairy story.
Winter called him far away;
Blossoms bring him home with May.
IV
Well, I know you’ll swear it’s true
That you found him decked in blue
Striding up through morning-land
With a cloud on either hand.
Out in Wales, you’ll say, he marches
Arm-in-arm with oaks and larches;
Hides all night in hilly nooks,
Laughs at dawn in tumbling brooks.
Yet, it’s certain, here he teaches
Outpost-schemes to groups of beeches.
And I’m sure, as here I stand,
That he shines through every land,
That he sings in every place
Where we’re thinking of his face.
V
Robert, there’s a war in France;
Everywhere men bang and blunder,
Sweat and swear and worship Chance,
Creep and blink through cannon thunder.
Rifles crack and bullets flick,
Sing and hum like hornet-swarms.
Bones are smashed and buried quick.
Yet, through stunning battle storms,
All the while I watch the spark
Lit to guide me; for I know
Dreams will triumph, though the dark
Scowls above me where I go.
You can hear me; you can mingle
Radiant folly with my jingle.
War’s a joke for me and you
While we know such dreams are true!
© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes
Analysis (AI Assisted)
This poem, written by Siegfried Sassoon during World War I to his friend Robert Graves, carries a unique blend of detachment, longing, and defiance. It’s not just a description of life in the trenches but also a snapshot of the soldier’s inner world—a world where the harsh realities of war are pushed aside in favor of memories, dreams, and a stubborn belief in something greater than the madness of battle. There’s humor here, but it’s a bitter sort of humor that cuts through the darkness of war, offering brief moments of solace amidst the suffering.
In the first stanza, the speaker presents himself as removed from the chaos of the war. Sitting in a quiet attic room, “France goes rolling all around,” which contrasts the peace of his current situation with the violence outside. The pipe-smoking, calm-hearted soldier seems to have distanced himself from the war, reflecting on how it all started and wondering when it will end. His cynicism is clear: “Back to hell with Kaiser sent it,” and he suggests that war is like a machine—“Clockwork soldiers in a row”—where men are pushed around without real control. The speaker doesn’t want to waste time on war anymore. His disillusionment comes across clearly, and it seems as if he’s more interested in the passing of time and in doing something more worthwhile than continuing to fight.
The second stanza moves into a dreamlike realm. As the speaker drifts off to sleep, he imagines chasing Robert Graves through a landscape full of shifting dreams and strange images. The lines “Over hedges hasting after / Crooked smile and baffling laughter” suggest a feeling of running after something unattainable, or perhaps a friend who has left the speaker behind in the physical world but is still very much alive in his mind. Graves, in this vision, is not just a figure of the past but a living, laughing presence—an escape from the harshness of reality. The imagery of “web-hung woods and valleys” and “glowworm stars” evokes a world of nostalgia and beauty, a world far removed from the violence of the front lines. There’s a clear yearning for a simpler, more carefree existence here.
The third stanza shifts to reflect on a shared history. The speaker and Graves have endured hardship together, notably “in the starving winter weather,” a memory of hard times that bonds them. There’s a wistfulness in the lines “Time’s too short and friends are few,” but also a quiet acknowledgment of how important their friendship is in a world where loss is inevitable. The speaker remembers a third friend, “whose yellow head was kissed / By the gods,” a figure who seems almost mythic in nature—someone loved by the gods themselves, whose death is mourned deeply by the speaker. The return of this friend, through the imagery of a “prince in a fairy story,” offers a brief moment of joy, a fairy-tale-like return to something pure and good amid the war’s horrors. The cyclical nature of the seasons, with blossoms bringing the friend home in May, underscores a sense of renewal, even in the midst of death.
In the fourth stanza, the speaker indulges in a more fantastical interpretation of his lost friend. He imagines Graves encountering this friend in a version of Wales that’s steeped in magic and mystery. The friend is no longer bound by the physical world but walks “Arm-in-arm with oaks and larches,” an image that suggests he is now part of the landscape, perhaps in a spiritual sense. The idea that this friend “teaches / Outpost-schemes to groups of beeches” blurs the line between the real and the imaginary, turning nature itself into a place of instruction and memory. There’s a certain tenderness in how the speaker imagines his friend’s continued existence—his friend shines “through every land” and sings “in every place.” This belief in the continued presence of the dead is not unusual in war, where men often turn to the spiritual or the imaginary to cope with loss.
The final stanza returns to the grim reality of the war. The speaker notes the chaos and violence of battle: “men bang and blunder, / Sweat and swear and worship Chance.” But even amid the noise and destruction, he holds onto a guiding light, a “spark” that keeps him going. This spark could symbolize hope, memory, or even the dreams that continue to guide him. The soldier insists that even though the darkness of war surrounds him, “dreams will triumph,” suggesting that the imagination, the shared bonds of friendship, and the memory of the lost can provide a kind of resistance to the horrors of war. “War’s a joke for me and you / While we know such dreams are true!” This line stands as both a defiant rejection of the war’s senselessness and a reminder of what sustains the speaker. It’s a bitter yet hopeful conclusion, where the power of dreams and memories becomes a form of rebellion against the brutality of the present.
This poem offers a powerful view of the psychological and emotional landscape of a soldier during World War I. On one hand, it presents the disillusionment and detachment that comes with prolonged exposure to violence and death. On the other hand, it shows how the human mind copes with the unimaginable through dreams, memories, and deep connections to others. The soldier’s fantasies and recollections act as a lifeline—pulling him out of the hell of war, even if just for a moment. The poem is not just about the horrors of battle but about how soldiers fight to preserve a sense of humanity in the face of it. It’s a reminder that, even when the body is trapped in the trenches, the mind can escape into dreams, memories, and the bonds of friendship.