Charles Sorley
We burrowed night and day with tools of lead,
Heaped the bank up and cast it in a ring
And hurled the earth above. And Caesar said,
“Why, it is excellent. I like the thing.”
We, who are dead,
Made it, and wrought, and Caesar liked the thing.
And here we strove, and here we felt each vein
Ice-bound, each limb fast-frozen, all night long.
And here we held communion with the rain
That lashed us into manhood with its thong,
Cleansing through pain.
And the wind visited us and made us strong.
Up from around us, numbers without name,
Strong men and naked, vast, on either hand
Pressing us in, they came. And the wind came
And bitter rain, turning grey all the land.
That was our game,
To fight with men and storms, and it was grand.
For many days we fought them, and our sweat
Watered the grass, making it spring up green,
Blooming for us. And, if the wind was wet,
Our blood wetted the wind, making it keen
With the hatred
And wrath and courage that our blood had been.
So, fighting men and winds and tempests, hot
With joy and hate and battle-lust, we fell
Where we fought. And God said, “Killed at last then? What?
Ye that are too strong for heaven, too clean for hell,
(God said) stir not.
This be your heaven, or, if ye will, your hell.”
So again we fight and wrestle, and again
Hurl the earth up and cast it in a ring.
But when the wind comes up, driving the rain
(Each rain-drop a fiery steed), and the mists rolling
Up from the plain,
This wild procession, this impetuous thing,
Hold us amazed. We mount the wind-cars, then
Whip up the steeds and drive through all the world.
Searching to find somewhere some brethren.
Sons of the winds and waters of the world.
We, who were men.
Have sought, and found no men in all this world.
Wind, that has blown here always ceaselessly.
Bringing, if any man can understand,
Might to the mighty, freedom to the free;
Wind, that has caught us, cleansed us, made us grand
Wind that is we
(We that were men)–make men in all this land,
That so may live and wrestle and hate that when
They fall at last exultant, as we fell,
And come to God, God may say, “Do you come then
Mildly enquiring, is it heaven or hell?
Why! Ye were men!
Back to your winds and rains. Be these your heaven and hell!”
_24 March 1913_
© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes
You may find this and other poems here.
Analysis (AI Assisted)
This poem feels like a conversation with both history and the elements, told by voices that no longer belong to the living. It’s packed with the rhythms of work, battle, and nature, each blending into the other. There’s an odd harmony between the men and the forces around them—Caesar’s soldiers working under rain and wind, wrestling with enemies and weather alike, and later becoming part of that same natural chaos in death. The poem treats war and nature as relentless, almost equal adversaries, but it also elevates them to something more—a brutal path to strength, cleansing, and even meaning.
The imagery is tough and unsentimental. There’s no soft glow around the soldiers’ struggle. The rain doesn’t soothe—it lashes them. The wind doesn’t whisper—it visits like a drill sergeant. Blood doesn’t simply spill—it mingles with the air, turning it into something sharper. These aren’t just soldiers fighting other men; they’re fighting the very world they stand on, and somehow, they’re at home in that fight. There’s no pity in their voices, no complaint, just the raw energy of the work they’re doing and the battles they’re waging.
What’s striking is how the poem takes death and stretches it out, making it endless. These soldiers don’t rest after they fall. They stay in motion, now part of the wind and rain they once endured. They become something elemental, driving storms across the world, looking for others like them, searching for men who match their ferocity and resilience. It’s haunting because they find no one. The world seems emptied of the kind of men they were, and they’re left to roam, still restless, still seeking.
At its core, the poem seems to ask what it means to be human—or more specifically, what it means to be a *man* in the face of struggle. There’s a sense that strength, courage, and even hatred are part of the answer, but so is the willingness to confront forces bigger than oneself. The soldiers aren’t looking for peace; they’re looking for the same wild fight that defined them in life. When they finally reach God, he doesn’t offer comfort or judgment. Instead, he seems to shrug, acknowledging their ferocity and sending them back to the winds and rains they’ve become.
The repetition of nature’s role throughout the poem is relentless. Wind and rain aren’t just background—they’re characters, companions, adversaries, and eventually, the essence of the men themselves. There’s a strange comfort in that transformation, as if the soldiers, stripped of everything else, find their truest selves in the storm.
This poem doesn’t offer answers or resolutions. It doesn’t glorify war, though it doesn’t shy away from its grim allure. Instead, it presents war as a crucible, a place where men are forged into something both grand and terrible. And when they fall, they don’t leave the world behind—they become part of its wild, untamable forces, caught in a kind of eternal struggle that might be heaven or hell, or maybe just life stripped down to its barest, rawest elements.