Herman Melville
Head-board and foot-board duly placed–
Grassed in the mound between;
Daniel Drouth is the slumberer’s name–
Long may his grave be green!
Quick was his way–a flash and a blow,
Full of his fire was he–
A fire of hell–’tis burnt out now–
Green may his grave long be!
May his grave be green, though he
Was a rebel of iron mould;
Many a true heart–true to the Cause,
Through the blaze of his wrath lies cold.
May his grave be green–still green
While happy years shall run;
May none come nigh to disinter
The–Buried Gun.
Poet’s Note:
Shortly prior to the evacuation of Petersburg, the enemy, with a view to ultimate repossession, interred some of his heavy guns in the same field with his dead, and with every circumstance calculated to deceive. Subsequently the negroes exposed the stratagem.
© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes
You may find this and other poems here.
Analysis (AI Assisted)
This poem, written with Melville’s typical restraint and moral tension, gains another layer when read with his note about the “buried gun.” The explanation—of Confederate forces hiding artillery among their dead to deceive their pursuers—turns what might first appear to be a simple elegy into something far darker and more complex. The poem’s grave is not only the resting place of a soldier; it is a trap. The mound marked with Daniel Drouth’s name conceals both a corpse and a weapon, blurring the line between mourning and deceit, burial and warfare. Melville seizes on this tension and turns it into a meditation on what it means to end a war that refuses to end.
Daniel Drouth becomes a stand-in for the rebellion itself: passionate, violent, unyielding, and deceitful even in defeat. The poet calls him “Quick … a flash and a blow,” suggesting both his impulsive temperament and his short life. His “fire of hell” signals not only his fury but also the moral inversion of his cause—an energy that could not last. Melville’s repeated refrain, “May his grave be green,” at first sounds like a gesture of respect toward the dead, the kind of closing benediction that war poetry often gives even to enemies. But the repetition shifts tone as the poem progresses. It becomes less a blessing and more a warning, almost an incantation to keep the earth undisturbed. The wish for the grave to remain “green” is a wish for the violence to stay buried.
The biographical detail that the “enemy” buried guns with their dead transforms the poem’s surface calm into irony. The “Buried Gun” of the last line is literal—a concealed weapon meant to harm those who come too close—but it is also symbolic of a continuing danger that lingers beneath the surface of peace. Melville’s use of a name, “Daniel Drouth,” gives the illusion of individuality, but the man is almost certainly fictional, a representative of a certain Southern type. “Drouth” evokes drought, dryness, barrenness—something burned out and unrenewed. The man and the weapon buried together form a single image of death fused with deception, suggesting that even in defeat, the rebellion leaves behind something toxic and unresolved.
The repeated refrain, “May his grave be green,” works on two levels. On one hand, it reads as the poet’s restrained attempt to extend a form of mercy to the enemy dead. On the other, it sounds like a nervous mantra meant to keep the past from erupting again. The more he repeats it, the less certain it feels. The final plea—“May none come nigh to disinter / The—Buried Gun”—confirms that unease. Melville’s break in rhythm before “Buried Gun” allows the phrase to hang in the air, half curse and half prayer. The poem closes not with resolution but with caution. The war may be over, but beneath the ground, its remnants still wait.
Melville’s choice to present this scene through understatement rather than outrage makes it more unsettling. He does not condemn the deceit outright; instead, he folds it into a kind of grim acknowledgment of human nature in war. There’s no triumph here, only the uneasy recognition that the same drive that made men fierce in battle could make them deceptive in defeat. The poem treats this not as an aberration but as a sign of how deeply the conflict has corrupted both sides.
The “green” grave, then, is not simply an image of renewal—it’s camouflage. It hides the violence beneath it, as the grass hides the gun. Melville’s tone, deliberately measured, keeps pity and suspicion in balance. He allows the soldier his rest but refuses to romanticize him. The act of burial, which should mark the end of struggle, becomes part of the struggle itself. Even in peace, the machinery of war remains literally and spiritually underground.
By tying the moral reflection of the poem to a real battlefield deception, Melville finds a way to comment on the unfinished nature of the American Civil War’s peace. The poem ends not with closure but with vigilance. The war’s fires are “burnt out now,” but the buried gun remains—a warning that some causes, though defeated, continue to smolder under the soil.