Herman Melville
Hard pressed by numbers in his strait,
Rebellion’s soldier-chief no more contends—
Feels that the hour is come of Fate,
Lays down one sword, and widened warfare ends.
The captain who fierce armies led
Becomes a quiet seminary’s head—
Poor as his privates, earns his bread.
In studious cares and aims engrossed,
Strives to forget Stuart and Stonewall dead—
Comrades and cause, station and riches lost,
And all the ills that flock when fortune’s fled.
No word he breathes of vain lament,
Mute to reproach, nor hears applause—
His doom accepts, perforce content,
And acquiesces in asserted laws;
Secluded now would pass his life,
And leave to time the sequel of the strife.
But missives from the Senators ran;
Not that they now would gaze upon a swordless foe,
And power made powerless and brought low:
Reasons of state, ’tis claimed, require the man.
Demurring not, promptly he comes
By ways which show the blackened homes,
And—last—the seat no more his own,
But Honor’s; patriot grave-yards fill
The forfeit slopes of that patrician hill,
And fling a shroud on Arlington.
The oaks ancestral all are low;
No more from the porch his glance shall go
Ranging the varied landscape o’er,
Far as the looming Dome—no more.
One look he gives, then turns aside,
Solace he summons from his pride:
“So be it! They await me now
Who wrought this stinging overthrow;
They wait me; not as on the day
Of Pope’s impelled retreat in disarray—
By me impelled—when toward yon Dome
The clouds of war came rolling home”
The burst, the bitterness was spent,
The heart-burst bitterly turbulent,
And on he fared.
In nearness now
He marks the Capitol—a show
Lifted in amplitude, and set
With standards flushed with a glow of Richmond yet;
Trees and green terraces sleep below.
Through the clear air, in sunny light,
The marble dazes—a temple white.
Intrepid soldier! had his blade been drawn
For yon stirred flag, never as now
Bid to the Senate-house had he gone,
But freely, and in pageant borne,
As when brave numbers without number, massed,
Plumed the broad way, and pouring passed—
Bannered, beflowered—between the shores
Of faces, and the dinn’d huzzas,
And balconies kindling at the sabre-flash,
’Mid roar of drums and guns, and cymbal-crash,
While Grant and Sherman shone in blue—
Close of the war and victory’s long review.
Yet pride at hand still aidful swelled,
And up the hard ascent he held.
The meeting follows. In his mien
The victor and the vanquished both are seen—
All that he is, and what he late had been.
Awhile, with curious eyes they scan
The Chief who led invasion’s van—
Allied by family to one,
Founder of the Arch the Invader warred upon:
Who looks at Lee must think of Washington;
In pain must think, and hide the thought,
So deep with grievous meaning it is fraught.
Secession in her soldier shows
Silent and patient; and they feel
(Developed even in just success)
Dim inklings of a hazy future steal;
Their thoughts their questions well express:
“Does the sad South still cherish hate?
Freely will Southen men with Northern mate?
The blacks—should we our arm withdraw,
Would that betray them? some distrust your law.
And how if foreign fleets should come—
Would the South then drive her wedges home”
And more hereof. The Virginian sees—
Replies to such anxieties.
Discreet his answers run—appear
Briefly straightforward, coldly clear.
“If now,” the Senators, closing, say,
“Aught else remain, speak out, we pray”
Hereat he paused; his better heart
Strove strongly then; prompted a worthier part
Than coldly to endure his doom.
Speak out? Ay, speak, and for the brave,
Who else no voice or proxy have;
Frankly their spokesman here become,
And the flushed North from her own victory save.
That inspiration overrode—
Hardly it quelled the galling load
Of personal ill. The inner feud
He, self-contained, a while withstood;
They waiting. In his troubled eye
Shadows from clouds unseen they spy;
They could not mark within his breast
The pang which pleading thought oppressed:
He spoke, nor felt the bitterness die.
“My word is given—it ties my sword;
Even were banners still abroad,
Never could I strive in arms again
While you, as fit, that pledge retain.
Our cause I followed, stood in field and gate—
All’s over now, and now I follow Fate.
But this is naught. A People call—
A desolted land, and all
The brood of ills that press so sore,
The natural offspring of this civil war,
Which ending not in fame, such as might rear
Fitly its sculptured trophy here,
Yields harvest large of doubt and dread
To all who have the heart and head
To feel and know. How shall I speak?
Thoughts knot with thoughts, and utterance check.
Before my eyes there swims a haze,
Through mists departed comrades gaze—
First to encourage, last that shall upbraid!
How shall I speak? The South would fain
Feel peace, have quiet law again—
Replant the trees for homestead-shade.
You ask if she recants: she yields.
Nay, and would more; would blend anew,
As the bones of the slain in her forests do,
Bewailed alike by us and you.
A voice comes out from these charnel-fields,
A plaintive yet unheeded one:
‘Died all in vain? both sides undone’
Push not your triumph; do not urge
Submissiveness beyond the verge.
Intestine rancor would you bide,
Nursing eleven sliding daggers in your side?
Far from my thought to school or threat;
I speak the things which hard beset.
Where various hazards meet the eyes,
To elect in magnanimity is wise.
Reap victory’s fruit while sound the core;
What sounder fruit than re-established law?
I know your partial thoughts do press
Solely on us for war’s unhappy stress;
But weigh—consider—look at all,
And broad anathema you’ll recall.
The censor’s charge I’ll not repeat,
The meddlers kindled the war’s white heat—
Vain intermeddlers and malign,
Both of the palm and of the pine;
I waive the thought—which never can be rife—
Common’s the crime in every civil strife:
But this I feel, that North and South were driven
By Fate to arms. For our unshriven,
What thousands, truest souls, were tried—
As never may any be again—
All those who stemmed Secession’s pride,
But at last were swept by the urgent tide
Into the chasm. I know their pain.
A story here may be applied:
‘In Moorish lands there lived a maid
Brought to confess by vow the creed
Of Christians. Fain would priests persuade
That now she must approve by deed
The faith she kept. “What dead?” she asked.
“Your old sire leave, nor deem it sin,
And come with us.” Still more they tasked
The sad one: “If heaven you’d win—
Far from the burning pit withdraw,
Then must you learn to hate your kin,
Yea, side against them—such the law,
For Moor and Christian are at war”
“Then will I never quit my sire,
But here with him through every trial go,
Nor leave him though in flames below—
God help me in his fire!”
So in the South; vain every plea
’Gainst Nature’s strong fidelity;
True to the home and to the heart,
Throngs cast their lot with kith and kin,
Foreboding, cleaved to the natural part—
Was this the unforgivable sin?
These noble spirits are yet yours to win.
Shall the great North go Sylla’s way?
Proscribe? prolong the evil day?
Confirm the curse? infix the hate?
In Unions name forever alienate?
“From reason who can urge the plea—
Freemen conquerors of the free?
When blood returns to the shrunken vein,
Shall the wound of the Nation bleed again?
Well may the wars wan thought supply,
And kill the kindling of the hopeful eye,
Unless you do what even kings have done
In leniency—unless you shun
To copy Europe in her worst estate—
Avoid the tyranny you reprobate.”
He ceased. His earnestness unforeseen
Moved, but not swayed their former mien;
And they dismissed him. Forth he went
Through vaulted walks in lengthened line
Like porches erst upon the Palatine:
Historic reveries their lesson lent,
The Past her shadow through the Future sent.
But no. Brave though the Soldier, grave his plea—
Catching the light in the future’s skies,
Instinct disowns each darkening prophecy:
Faith in America never dies;
Heaven shall the end ordained fulfill,
We march with Providence cheery still.
Poet’s Note:
Among those summoned during the spring just passed to appear before the Reconstruction Committee of Congress was Robert E. Lee. His testimony is deeply interesting, both in itself and as coming from him. After various questions had been put and briefly answered, these words were addressed to him:
“If there be any other matter about which you wish to speak on this occasions, do so freely.” Waiving this invitation, he responded by a short personal explanation of some point in a previous answer, and after a few more brief questions and replies, the interview closed.
In the verse a poetical liberty has been ventured. Lee is not only represented as responding to the invitation, but also as at last renouncing his cold reserve, doubtless the cloak to feelings more or less poignant. If for such freedom warrant be necessary the speeches in ancient histories, not to speak of those in Shakespeare’s historic plays, may not unfitly perhaps be cited.
The character of the original measures proposed about time in the National Legislature for the treatment of the (as yet) Congressionally excluded South, and the spirit in which those measures were advocated—these are circumstances which it is fairly supposable would have deeply influenced the thoughts, whether spoken or withheld, of a Southerner placed in the position of Lee before the Reconstruction Committee.
© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes
You may find this and other poems here.
Analysis (AI Assisted)
This poem takes on one of the most complicated moments in the aftermath of the Civil War: the surrender of the Confederacy and Robert E. Lee’s visit to Washington. Instead of retelling events in a straightforward historical way, the poem tries to get inside the emotional pressure of that situation. It presents Lee as a defeated commander carrying the weight of everything lost—lives, land, reputation, and the collapse of the world he fought to preserve. At the same time, it shows the Union leadership trying to understand what comes next, unsure how far to trust a beaten enemy and how much punishment or leniency is right. The poem’s strength lies in how it handles these tensions without reducing either side to simple roles.
The opening takes a calm, almost restrained view of Lee after the surrender. He is shown not as a fiery leader but as a quiet man trying to disappear into an academic job. The poem emphasizes how far he has fallen from military command to a modest life, and how he carries that change without complaint. This version of Lee is not dramatic; he is exhausted and resigned. The landscape he travels through reinforces that mood. Burned houses, ruined hillsides, and cemeteries remind him—and the reader—of what the war consumed. Arlington becomes a symbol of this shift: once a family estate, now a national graveyard. The poem uses this transformation to underline the point that the old world cannot be reclaimed.
When Lee arrives in Washington, the poem shows him through the eyes of the Senators. They look at him with curiosity, suspicion, and a sense of history. The mention of his connection to Washington creates an uncomfortable contrast between the founding ideals and the rebellion. The Senators’ questions focus on practical worries: Southern resentment, Black safety, foreign interference, and the stability of the postwar nation. The poem doesn’t portray them as hostile, just uneasy. Their concerns feel rooted in the reality of Reconstruction, when no one knew if the peace would last.
Lee’s responses form the center of the poem. He answers carefully, almost coldly, but when pressed, he allows something more honest through. His speech becomes a plea for moderation, not in service of the Confederate cause, but in service of national recovery. He argues that pushing the South too hard will prolong bitterness and make reconciliation harder. This part of the poem handles a difficult subject without turning it into a defense of the rebellion. Instead, it describes the emotional loyalty that kept many Southerners on the Confederate side, even those uneasy with secession. The comparison to the Moorish daughter highlights that theme: people often choose family and home over abstract arguments. The poem presents this explanation without saying it excuses anything. It’s simply an attempt to understand the human decision-making behind the war.
The poem also acknowledges Northern fears about justice. Questions about loyalty, security, and the rights of freedpeople sit just under the surface. Lee’s words don’t dissolve these fears, but they try to address them through a call for restraint. The Senators remain unmoved, which keeps the poem from drifting into romanticism. Their caution represents the real political atmosphere, where trust was fragile and the stakes were high.
The closing lines shift away from Lee and turn toward a broader view of the country. The poem hints that despite all the worry and argument, the nation will find its way forward. The image of walking past structures that echo Roman ruins gives the scene a sense of historic weight, but the final tone is hopeful. The poem suggests that America has a way of stumbling through crises and still moving ahead.
Overall, the poem works because it doesn’t glorify Lee or the Confederacy, and it doesn’t simplify the Union’s position either. It captures the emotional aftermath of the war: exhaustion, pride, uncertainty, and the complicated need to rebuild relationships after a violent break. The poem’s slow pacing and long reflections match the heavy mood of Reconstruction. Instead of aiming for grand statements, it tries to show what it feels like when a country tries to stitch itself back together while old wounds are still fresh.