Robert Vernède
If thro’ the roar o’ the guns one prayer may reach Thee,
Lord of all Life, whose mercies never sleep,
Not in our time, not now, Lord, we beseech Thee
To grant us peace. The sword has bit too deep.
We may not rest. We hear the wail of mothers
Mourning the sons who fill some nameless grave:
Past us, in dreams, the ghosts march of our brothers
Who were most valiant . . . whom we could not save.
We may not rest. What though our eyes be holden,
In sleep we see dear eyes wet with tears,
And locks that once were, oh, so fair and golden,
Grown grey in hours more pitiless than years.
We see all fair things fouled – homes love’s hands builded
Shattered to dust beside their withered vines,
Shattered the towers that once Thy sunsets gilded,
And Christ stuck yet again within his shrines
Over them hangs the dust of death, beside them
The dead lie countless – and the foe laughs still;
We may not rest, while those cruel mouths deride them,
We, who were prod, yet could not work Thy will.
We have failed – we have been more weak than these betrayers –
In strength or in faith we have failed; our pride was vain.
How can we rest, who have not slain the slayers?
What peace for us, who have seen Thy children slain?
Hark, the roar grows . . . the thunders reawaken –
We ask one thing, Lord, only one thing now:
Hearts high as theirs, who went to death unshaken,
Courage like theirs to make and keep their vow.
To stay not till these hosts whom mercies harden,
Who know no glory save of sword and fire,
Find in our fire the splendour of Thy pardon,
Meet from our steel the mercy they desire . . .
Then to our children there shall be no handing
Of fates so vain – of passions so abhorr’d . . .
But Peace . . . the Peace which passeth understanding . . .
Not in our time . . . but in their time, O Lord.
© by owner. provided at no charge for educational purposes
You may find this and other poems here.
Analysis (AI Assisted)
This war poem presents a deeply reflective and poignant meditation on the impact of war, emphasizing the toll it takes on both the individual and collective soul. The speaker, likely a soldier or someone intimately connected to the war effort, begins with a prayer, pleading for peace after enduring the violence and destruction of battle. Through its tone and structure, the poem communicates the weariness of those who have lived through the conflict, their inability to find rest or solace until a greater resolution is achieved.
From the outset, the poem contrasts the immediate, brutal realities of war with the speaker’s longing for peace. The line “We may not rest” recurs throughout the poem, capturing the sense of guilt, loss, and unresolved grief that defines the speaker’s experience. The speaker is haunted by images of mothers mourning their sons, ghosts of fallen comrades, and the devastation that war has wrought on the land and its people. These vivid images emphasize the heavy burden of those left behind, who must carry the emotional and moral weight of the war, even as they search for peace.
In the second stanza, the speaker conveys the haunting nature of their memories, where even sleep does not provide refuge. Instead, it brings visions of the lives lost, of once-beautiful things turned to ruin, reinforcing the theme of irreversible destruction. The speaker’s sorrow is compounded by a sense of impotence—despite the fight, they could not save their comrades, and they feel responsible for failing to protect those they loved.
The poem turns increasingly contemplative, particularly as the speaker begins to question the moral implications of the war. The repeated phrase “we may not rest” becomes a manifestation of the speaker’s ongoing struggle with guilt and regret. The failures of the past seem insurmountable, and the speaker acknowledges that they are complicit in the suffering and violence that continue to rage. There is a strong sense of personal accountability, as the speaker recognizes that they have not fully succeeded in fulfilling their moral duty.
However, the poem also contains a glimmer of hope through the speaker’s call for strength and courage—qualities they admire in those who have gone to their deaths unshaken. The speaker prays for the courage to act in accordance with the principles of mercy, honor, and justice, even in the face of continued violence. There is a stark contrast between the “mercies harden[ed]” by war and the idealized mercy that the speaker hopes to achieve. The repeated invocation of peace represents the speaker’s hope for a better future, one in which their children will not inherit the same cycle of violence and loss.
Ultimately, the poem is a meditation on the futility of war and the enduring hope for peace, even if that peace is not realized in the speaker’s time. The speaker acknowledges the impossibility of fully understanding or achieving peace during the horrors of war, but they leave open the possibility that future generations will be spared from the same fate.
Through its rhythmic structure and repeated lines, the poem conveys both the despair of the present and the hope for the future. The speaker’s prayer is not only a plea for mercy and peace but also a profound expression of the internal conflict faced by those who must reconcile their participation in war with their desire for redemption. The poem speaks to the universal desire for peace, but it also asks difficult questions about the human cost of war, the consequences of violence, and the possibility of healing.